Steve Mentz

THE BOOKFISH

THALASSOLOGY, SHAKESPEARE, AND SWIMMING

  • Home
  • Steve Mentz
  • Humanities Commons
  • Public Writing
  • The sea! the sea!
  • The Bookfish
  • St. Johns

Early Modern Theatricality at Rutgers

December 5, 2011 by Steve Mentz Leave a Comment

I caught the last half of a lively two-day conference at Rutgers last Friday.  Early Modern Theatricality in the 21st Century, organized by Henry Turner, brought an international crew together to put pressure on “theatricality.”   The organizing gambit was 10-minute papers and one-word titles, from “now” (Scott Maisano) to “formactions” (Simon Palfrey)  to “festivity” (Erika Lim) and “indecorum” (Ellen MacKay), plus a few dozen others.  I missed the early sessions, at which Henry seems to have entertained the crowd with multiple dramatic readings of the conference’s one-paragraph blurb, but caught the last 13 speakers in 2 sessions.

A couple things struck me.  Most of all was the concentrated effort to expand  theatricality’s range, to move this concept away from familiar haunts.  I missed Peter Womack’s “Offstage,” but many of the talks gestured beyond the wooden O to street festivals or Parliament or philosophy.  Even when we stayed on or near the stage, we often lurked at the margins, or at the borders between players and audience.

The presentations also collectively showed how little current criticism defines early modern drama as consubstantial with Shakespeare.  Will made some appearances, but his plays were part of a group and a broad culture of theatrical practice.  Perhaps the signature moment of this tendency came when Mike Witmore semi-apologized for drawing all the examples in his talk about “eventuality” from the final moments of Shakespeare’s romances, “because of where I work.”

Some familiar border skirmishes between history and literary habits showed themselves in a cluster of talks by Peter Lake (“Import”), Chris Kyle (“Parliament”) and Blair Hoxby (“Passions”), but in general the anachronism police were not in evidence.  Everyone seemed happy to think in divided chronologies, standing astride the 21st and 16th-17th centuries.  “Theatricality,” of course, is abstract enough to draw from both periods, w/o the special difficulties of a 19c term such as “ecology.”

I was left mulling about limits and senses of ending.  One of the things I love about going to the theater is that it ends, the curtain closes, and we get to go home.  If we invest our critical energies in pushing theatricality offstage, might we risk attenuating the pleasures of closure?  Where might theatricality end?  There is a significant performative aspect to all human interactions, but might the difference between theatricality and performativity be that theatricality is a sub-set, a special case in which a certain space and time gets marked off as different, temporary, luminous?  I’m tempted to think so.

We ran out of time before I could ask whatever half-phrased version of that question I was trying to squeeze in, but Scott Maisano’s conference-ending comment also pointed toward the limit or borders of the theatrical transaction.  Scott observed that Britomart’s ordeal in the House of Busirane (FQ III.12) contains virtually all the features of theatricality the conference had raised — but, as Scott did not polemically conclude, can a poetic epic really be theatrical?  Mike Witmore had also framed his talk by describing the pleasurable and bewildering experience of teaching Heliodorus to undergrads — but when I chatted with him about that at the break, he suggested that the scene in the Ethiopian court was an ekphrasis of the theater, & thus, perhaps, about theatricality even if not presented on stage.

Clearly both Spenser and Heliodorus are thinking hard about theatricality– but surely these moments are not theatrical is the same sense as The Winter’s Tale or the Shoemaker’s Holiday or a Lord Mayor’s show or even a session of Parliament?  Don’t we need at least two real human bodies in a particular shared space and time to have theatricality?

Poetic epics and prose romances can be theatrical, or meta-theatrical, or engage in a critique of theatricality.  But I suspect that it might be worth drawing a distinction between a performative enactment in an at least partially marked-off time and space, and a textual product like a poem or a prose fiction.  There are lots kinds of of overlap and exchanges between page and stage, and artifacts like a film or a digital audio file might blur these lines, since they are artifacts that contain traces of “real” bodies.  The long tradition of oral recitation as a primary means of transmitting prose texts — the “fair ladies” in Sidney’s Arcadia — also pushes these two modes together.  But bodies and words still might be distinguishable from words alone.

 

 

 

Filed Under: Shakespeare

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Steve

Steve Mentz
Professor of English
St. John’s University
Read Bio

Twitter Feed

Steve Mentz Follow

Shakespearean. Ecocritic. Swimmer. New book Ocean #objectsobjects Professor at St. John's in NYC. #bluehumanities #pluralizetheanthropocene

stevermentz
stevermentz Steve Mentz @stevermentz ·
24 Mar

Day-after thoughts on Red Bull's Arden, up through April 1! https://stevementz.com/red-bulls-arden-of-faversham/

Reply on Twitter 1639266501109727235 Retweet on Twitter 1639266501109727235 Like on Twitter 1639266501109727235 2 Twitter 1639266501109727235
stevermentz Steve Mentz @stevermentz ·
21 Mar

I bought my ticket to this play a day before @SAAupdates secured this discount - but you should take advantage of it now!

Reply on Twitter 1638264709878099970 Retweet on Twitter 1638264709878099970 Like on Twitter 1638264709878099970 6 Twitter 1638264709878099970
Load More

Pages

  • #shax2022 s31: Rethinking the Early Modern Literary Caribbbean
  • OCEAN Publicity
  • #SAA 2020: Watery Thinking
  • Creating Nature: May 2019 at the Folger
  • Audio and Video Recordings
  • Oceanic New York
  • Public Writing
  • Published Work
  • #pluralizetheanthropocene

Recent Posts

  • Red Bull’s Arden of Faversham
  • Endgame at Irish Rep (NYC)
  • Responses to the NYer’s Doomcast
  • Water in the Desert
  • F22 at the Landhaus!

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in